Pittsburgh Pirates as Primary Team
- Jake Beckley, 1st Baseman, 1888-1889, 1891-1896, Class of 1971
- Max Carey, Center Fielder, 1910-1926, Class of 1961
- Fred Clarke, Left Fielder, 1900-1911, 1913-1915, Class of 1945
- Roberto Clemente, Right Fielder, 1955-1972, Class of 1973
- Barney Dreyfuss, Executive, 1900-1932, Class of 2008
- Ralph Kiner, Left Fielder, 1946-1953, Class of 1975
- Jim Leyland, Coach, 1986-1996, Class of 2024
- Bill Mazeroski, 2nd Baseman, 1956-1972, Class of 2001
- Willie Stargell, Left Fielder, 1962-1982, Class of 1988
- Pie Traynor, 3rd Baseman, 1920-1935, 1937, Class of 1948
- Arky Vaughan, Shortstop, 1932-1941, Class of 1985
- Honus Wagner, Shortstop, 1900-1917, Class of 1936
- Lloyd Waner, Center Fielder, 1927-1941, 1944-1945, Class of 1967
- Paul Waner, Right Fielder, 1926-1940, Class of 1952
Hall of Famers who also played for the Pittsburgh Pirates
- Jim Bunning, Pitcher, 1964-1967, 1970-1971, Class of 1996
- Jack Chesbro, Pitcher, 1899-1902, Class of 1946
- Kiki Cuyler, Right Fielder, 1921-1927, Class of 1968
- Goose Gossage, Pitcher, 1977, Class of 2008
- Burleigh Grimes, Pitcher, 1916-1917, 1928-1929, 1934, Class of 1964
- Hank Greenberg, 1st Baseman, 1947, Class of 1956
- Waite Hoyt, Pitcher, 1933-1937, Class of 1969
- George Kelly, 1st Baseman, 1927-1930, Class of 1973
- Chuck Klein, Right Fielder, 1939, Class of 1980
- Jim Leyland, Manager, 1986-1996, Class of 2024
- Freddie Lindstrom, 3rd Baseman, 1933-1934, Class of 1976
- Al López, Manager (as player), 1940-1946, Class of 1977
- Heinie Manush, Left Fielder, 1938-1939, Class of 1964
Carolina Panthers in the Hall of Fame
Reggie White, Defensive End, 2000, Class of 2006