Class of 2005
- The Gorilla, NBA – Phoenix Suns
- The Famous Chicken, Independent Professional Mascots
- Phillie Phanatic, MLB – Philadelphia Phillies
Class of 2006
- YoUDee, University of Delaware
- K. C. Wolf, NFL – Kansas City Chiefs
- Jazz Bear, NBA – Utah Jazz
- Clutch the Bear, NBA – Houston Rockets
- Bucky Badger, University of Wisconsin
- Aubie, Auburn University
Class of 2007
- The Coyote, NBA – San Antonio Spurs
- Mr. Met, MLB – New York Mets
- Lil’ Red, University of Nebraska
- Brutus Buckeye, Ohio State University
- Big Red, Western Kentucky University
Class of 2008
- Smokey, University of Tennessee
- Slider, MLB – Cleveland Guardians
- Rocky, NBA – Denver Nuggets
Class of 2017
- Tommy Hawk, NHL – Chicago Blackhawks
- Sluggerr, MLB – Kansas City Royals
- Nittany Lion, Penn State University
- Benny the Bull, NBA – Chicago Bulls
Class of 2019
- Youppi, NHL – Montreal Canadians
- The Oriole Bird, MLB – Baltimore Orioles
- Boomer, NBA – Indiana Pacers
- Blue, NFL – Indianapolis Colts
Class of 2022
- Southpaw, MLB – Chicago White Sox
- Globie, Independent Professional Mascots – Harlem Globetrotters
Class of 2023
- Slugger, MiLB AA Eastern – Portland Sea Dogs
- Otto the Orange, Syracuse University