Class of 1936
- Ty Cobb, Center Fielder, Detroit Tigers, Philadelphia A’s, 1905-1927
- Walter Johnson, Pitcher, Washington Senators, 1907-1927
- Christy Mathewson, Pitcher, New York Giants, Cincinnati Reds, 1900-1916
- Babe Ruth, Right Fielder, Boston Red Sox/New York Yankees/Boston Braves, 1914-1935
- Honus Wagner, Shortstop, Louisville Colonels/Pittsburgh Pirates, 1897-1917
Class of 1937
- Morgan Bulkeley, Executive/Pioneer, First President of the National League, 1876
- Byron “Ban” Johnson, Executive/Pioneer, Founder of the American League
- Napoleon “Nap” Lajoie, 2nd Baseman, Philadelphia Phillies/Philadelphia A’s/Cleveland Indians, 1896-1916
- Connie Mack, Manager, Philadelphia Athletics, 1894-1950
- John McGraw, Manager, New York Giants, 1899, 1901-1932
- Tris Speaker, Center Fielder, Boston Red Sox/Cleveland Indians/Washington Senators/Philadelphia A’s, 1907-1928
- George Wright, Executive/Pioneer, Boston Red Stockings/Boston Red Caps/Providence Grays, 1871-1882
- Denton True “Cy” Young, Pitcher, Boston Red Sox
Class of 1938
- Grover “Pete” Alexander, Pitcher, Philadelphia Phillies
- Alexander Cartwright, Executive/Pioneer, “Father of Modern Baseball”
- Henry Chadwick, Executive/Pioneer, Statistics & Rules
Class of 1939
- Adrian “Cap” Anson, 1st Baseman, Chicago White Stockings
- Eddie Collins, 2nd Baseman, Chicago White Sox
- Charlie Comiskey, Executive/Pioneer, Player/Manager/Owner, Co-founder of the American League
- Candy Cummings, Pitcher, Hartford Dark Blues
- Buck Ewing, Catcher, New York Gothams/Mutuals/Giants
- Lou Gehrig, 1st Baseman, New York Yankees
- Willie Keeler, Right Fielder, New York Highlanders
- Charley Radbourn, Pitcher, Providence Grays
- George Sisler, 1st Baseman, St. Louis Browns
- Al Spalding, Executive/Pioneer
Class of 1942
- Rogers Hornsby, 2nd Baseman, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 1944
- Kenesaw Landis, Executive/Pioneer, First Baseball Commissioner
Class of 1945
- Roger Bresnahan, Catcher, New York Giants
- Dan Brouthers, 1st Baseman, Buffalo Bisons
- Fred Clarke, Left Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Jimmy Collins, 3rd Baseman, Boston Red Sox
- Ed Delahanty, Left Fielder, Philadelphia Phillies
- Hugh Duffy, Center Fielder, Boston Beaneaters
- Hughie Jennings, Shortstop, Baltimore Orioles
- King Kelly, Right Fielder, Chicago White Stockings
- Jim O’Rourke, Left Fielder, New York Giants
- Wilbert Robinson, Manager, Brooklyn Dodgers
Class of 1946
- Jesse Burkett, Left Fielder, Cleveland Spiders
- Frank Chance, First Baseman, Chicago Cubs
- Jack Chesbro, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Johnny Evers, 2nd Baseman, Chicago Cubs
- Clark Griffith, Executive/Pioneer
- Tommy McCarthy, Right Fielder, Boston Beaneaters (Braves)
- Joe McGinnity, Pitcher, New York Giants
- Eddie Plank, Pitcher, Philadelphia Athletics
- Joe Tinker, Shortstop, Chicago Cubs
- Ed Walsh, Pitcher, Chicago White Sox
Class of 1947
- Mickey Cochrane, Catcher, Philadelphia Athletics
- Frankie Firsch, 2nd Baseman, St. Louis Cardinals
- Lefty Grove, Pitcher, Philadelphia Athletics
- Carl Hubbell, Pitcher, New York Giants
Class of 1948
- Herb Pennock, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Pie Traynor, 3rd Baseman, Pittsburgh Pirates
Class of 1949
- Mordecai Brown, Pitcher, Chicago Cubs
- Charlie Gehringer, 2nd Baseman, Detroit Tigers
Class of 1951
- Jimmie Foxx, 1st Baseman, Philadelphia Athletics
- Mel Ott, Right Fielder, New York Giants
Class of 1952
- Harry Hellmann, Right Fielder, Detroit Tigers
- Paul Waner, Right Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
Class of 1953
- Ed Barrow, Executive, New York Yankees
- Chief Bender, Pitcher, Philadelphia Athletics
- Tom Connolly, Umpire
- Dizzy Dean, Pitcher, St. Louis Cardinals
- Bill Klem, Umpire
- Al Simmons, Left Fielder, Philadelphia Athletics
- Bobby Wallace, Shortstop, St. Louis Browns
- Harry Wright, Manager, Philadelphia Quakers (Phillies)
Class of 1954
- Bill Dickey, Catcher, New York Yankees
- Walter “Rabbit” Maranville, Shortstop, Boston Braves
- Bill Terry, 1st Baseman, New York Giants
Class of 1955
- Frank Baker, 3rd Baseman, Philadelphia Athletics
- Joe DiMaggio, Center Fielder, New York Yankees
- Gabby Hartnett, Catcher, Chicago Cubs
- Ted Lyons, Pitcher, Chicago White Sox
- Ray Schalk, Catcher, Chicago White Sox
- Dazzy Vance, Pitcher, Brooklyn dodgers
Class of 1956
- Joe Cronin, Shortstop, Boston Red Sox
- Hank Greenberg, 1st Baseman, Detroit Tigers
Class of 1957
- Sam Crawford, Right Fielder, Detroit Tigers
- Joe McCarthy, Manager, New York Managers
Class of 1959
- Zack Wheat, Center Fielder, Brooklyn Dodgers
Class of 1961
- Max Carey, Center Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Billy Hamilton, Center Fielder, Philadelphia Phillies
Class of 1962
- Bob Feller, Pitcher, Cleveland Indians
- Bill McKechnie, Manager, Cincinnati Reds
- Jackie Robinson, 2nd Baseman, Brooklyn Dodgers
- Edd Roush, Center Fielder, Cincinnati Reds
Class of 1963
- John Clarkson, Pitcher, Boston Beaneaters (Braves)
- Elmer Flick, Center Fielder, Cleveland Indians
- Sam Rice, Right Fielder, Washington Senators
- Eppa Rixey, Pitcher, Cincinnati Reds
Class of 1964
- Luke Appling, Shortstop, Chicago White Sox
- Red Faber, Pitcher, Chicago White Sox
- Burleigh Grimes, Pitcher, Brooklyn Dodgers
- Miller Huggins, Manager, New York Yankees
- Tim Keefe, Pitcher, New York Giants
- Heinie Manush, Left Fielder, Washington Senators
- John Ward, Shortstop, New York Gothams/New York Giants
Class of 1965
- Jim Galvin, Pitcher, Buffalo Bisons
Class of 1966
- Casey Stengel, Manager, New York Yankees
- Ted Williams, Left Fielder, Boston Red Sox
Class of 1967
- Branch Rickey, Executive/Pioneer
- Red Ruffing, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Lloyd Wagner, Center Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
Class of 1968
- Kiki Cuyler, Left Fielder, Chicago Cubs
- Goose Goslin, Left Fielder, Washington Senators
- Joe Medwick, Left Fielder, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 1969
- Roy Campanella, Catcher, Brooklyn Dodgers
- Stan Coveleski, Pitcher, Cleveland Indians
- Waite Hoyt, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Stan Musial, Left Fielder, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 1970
- Lou Boudreau, Shortstop, Cleveland Indians
- Earle Combs, Center Fielder, New York Yankees
- Ford Frick, Executive/Pioneer
- Jesse Haines, Pitcher, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 1971
- Dave Bancroft, Shortstop, Philadelphia Phillies
- Jake Beckley, 1st Baseman, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Chick Hafey, Left Fielder, St. Louis Cardinals
- Harry Hooper, Right Fielder, Boston Red Sox
- Joe Kelley, Left Fielder, Baltimore Orioles
- Rube Marquard, Pitcher, New York Giants
- Satchel Paige, Pitcher, Kansas City Monarchs
- George Weiss, Executive/Pioneer
Class of 1972
- Yogi Berra, Catcher, New York Yankees
- Josh Gibson, Catcher, Homestead Grays
- Lefty Gomez, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Will Harridge, Executive/Pioneer
- Sandy Koufax, Pitcher, Los Angeles Dodgers
- Buck Leonard, 1st Baseman, Homestead Grays
- Early Wynn, Pitcher, Cleveland Indians
- Ross Youngs, Right Fielder, New York Giants
Class of 1973
- Roberto Clemente, Right Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Billy Evans, Umpire
- Monte Irvin, Left Fielder, Newark Eagles
- George Kelly, 1st Baseman, New York Giants
- Warren Spahn, Pitcher, Milwaukee Braves
- Mickey Welch, Pitcher, New York Giants
Class of 1974
- Cool Papa Bell, Center fielder, St. Louis Stars
- Jim Bottomley, 1st Baseman, St. Louis Cardinals
- Jocko Conlan, Umpire
- Edward Whitey Ford, Pitcher, New York Yankees
- Mickey Mantle, Center Fielder, New York Yankees
- Sam Thompson, Right Fielder, Philadelphia Phillies
Class of 1975
- Earl Averill, Center Fielder, Cleveland Indians
- Bucky Harris, Manager, Washington Senators
- Billy Herman, 2nd Baseman, Chicago Cubs
- Judy Johnson, 3rd Baseman, Hilldale Daisies
- Ralph Kiner, Left Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
Class of 1976
- Oscar Charleston, Center Fielder, Pittsburgh Crawfords
- Roger Connor, 1st Baseman, New York Gothams (Giants)
- Cal Hubbard, Umpire
- Bob Lemon, Pitcher, Cleveland Indians
- Freddie Lindstrom, 3rd Baseman, New York Giants
- Robin Roberts, Pitcher, Philadelphia Phillies
Class of 1977
- Ernie Banks, Shortstop, Chicago Cubs
- Martin Dihigo, Pitcher, Cuban Stars East
- Pop Lloyd, Shortstop, New York Lincoln Giants
- Al Lopez, Manager, Chicago White Sox
- Amos Rusie, Pitcher, New York Giants
- Joe Sewell, Shortstop, Cleveland Indians
Class of 1978
- Addie Joss, Pitcher, Cleveland Indians
- Larry MacPhail, Executive/Pioneer
- Eddie Mathews, 3rd Baseman, Milwaukee Braves
Class of 1979
- Warren Giles, Executive/Pioneer
- Willie Mays, Center Fielder, San Francisco Giants
- Hack Wilson, Center Fielder, Chicago Cubs
Class of 1980
- Al Kaline, Right Fielder, Detroit Tigers
- Chuck Klein, Right Fielder, Philadelphia Phillies
- Duke Snider, Center Fielder, Brooklyn Dodgers
- Tom Yawnkey, Executive/Pioneer
Class of 1981
- Rube Foster, Manager, Chicago American Giants
- Bob Gibson, Pitcher, St. Louis Cardinals
- Johnny Mize, 1st Baseman, St. Louis Cardinals
Class of 1982
- Hank Aaron, Right Fielder, Milwaukee Braves
- Happy Chandler, Executive/Pioneer
- Travis Jackson, Shortstop, New York Giants
- Frank Robinson, Right Fielder, Cincinnati Reds
Class of 1983
- Walter Alston, Manager, Los Angeles Dodgers
- George Kell, Third Baseman, Detroit Tigers
- Juan Marichal, Pitcher, San Francisco Giants
- Brooks Robinson, Third Baseman, Baltimore Orioles
Class of 1984
- Luis Aparicio, Shortstop, Chicago White Sox
- Don Drysdale, Pitcher, Los Angeles Dodgers
- Rick Ferrell, Catcher, St. Louis Browns
- Harmon Killebrew, First Baseman, Minnesota Twins
- Pee Wee Reese, Shortstop, Brooklyn Dodgers
Class of 1985
- Lou Brock, Left Fielder, St. Louis Cardinals
- Enox Slaughter, Right Fielder, St. Louis Cardinals
- Arky Vaughan, Shortstop, Pittsburgh Pirates
- Hoyt Wilhelm, Pitcher, Chicago White Sox
Class of 1986
- Bobby Doerr, Second Baseman, Boston Red Sox
- Ernie Lombardi, Catcher, Cincinnati Reds
- Willie McCovey, First Baseman, San Francisco Giants
Class of 1987
- Ray Dandridge, Third Baseman, Newark Eagles
- Catfish Hunter, Pitcher, Oakland Athletics
- Billy Williams, Left Fielder, Chicago Cubs
Class of 1988
- Willie Stargell, Left Fielder, Pittsburgh Pirates
Class of 1989
- Al Barlick, Umpire
- Johnny Bench, Catcher, Cincinnati Reds
- Red Schoendienst, Second Baseman, St. Louis Cardinals
- Carl Yastrzemski, Left Fielder, Boston Red Sox
Class of 1990
- Joe Morgan, Second Baseman, Cincinnati Reds
- Jim Palmer, Pitcher, Baltimore Orioles
Class of 1991
- Rod Carew, Second Baseman, Minnesota Twins
- Fergie Jenkins, Pitcher, Chicago Cubs
- Tony Lazzeri, Second Baseman, New York Yankees
- Gaylord Perry, Pitcher, San Francisco Giants
- Bill Veeck, Executive/Pioneer
Class of 1992
- Rollie Fingers, Pitcher, Oakland Athletics
- Bill McGowan, Umpire
- Hal Newhouser, Pitcher, Detroit Tigers
- Tom Seaver, Pitcher, New York Mets
Class of 1993
- Reggie Jackson, Right Fielder, Oakland Athletics
Class of 1994
- Steve Carlton, Pitcher, Philadelphia Phillies
- Leo Durocher, Manager, Brooklyn dodgers
- Phil Rizzuto, Shortstop, New York Yankees
Class of 1995
- Richie Ashburn, Center Fielder, Philadelphia Phillies
- Leon Day, Pitcher, Newark Eagles
- William Hulbert, Executive/Pioneer
- Mike Schmidt, Third Baseman, Philadelphia Phillies
- Vic Willis, Pitcher, Boston Braves
Class of 1996
- Jim Bunning, Pitcher, Detroit Tigers
- Bill Foster, Pitcher, Chicago American Giants
- Ned Hanlon, Manager, Baltimore Orioles (National League)
- Earl Weaver, Manager, Baltimore Orioles
Class of 1997
- Nellie Fox, Second Baseman, Chicago White Sox
- Tommy Lasorda, Manager, Los Angeles Dodgers
- Phil Niekro, Pitcher, Atlanta Braves
- Willie Wells, Shortstop, St. Louis Stars
Class of 1998
- George Davis, Shortstop, New York Giants
- Larry Doby, Center Fielder, Cleveland Indians
- Lee MacPhail, Executive/Pioneer
- Bullet Rogan, Pitcher, Kansas City Monarchs
- Don Sutton, Pitcher, Los Angeles Dodgers
Class of 1999
- George Brett, Third Baseman, Kansas City Royals
- Orlando Cepeda, First Baseman, San Francisco Giants
- Nestor Chylak, Umpire
- Nolan Ryan, Pitcher, California Angels
- Frank Selee, Manager, Boston Beaneaters (Braves)
- Joe Williams, Pitcher, New York Linkcoln Giants
- Robin Yount, Shortstop, Milwaukee Brewers
Class of 2000
- Sparky Anderson, Manager, Detroit Tigers
- Carlton Fisk, Catcher, Chicago White Sox
- Bid McPhee, Second Baseman, Cincinnati Red Stockings
- Tony Perez, First Baseman, Cincinnati Reds
- Turkey Stearnes, Center Fielder, Detroit Stars