Class of 1961
- Charley Caldwell, Coach, Williams/Princeton, 1928-1956
- Glenn “Mr. Outside” Davis, Halfback, Army, 1943-1946
- Don Faurot, Coach, Northeast Missouri/Missouri, 1926-1956
- Weldon Humble, Guard, Rice/Louisiana-Lafayette, 1941-1943, 1946
- Charlie “Choo Choo” Justice, Halfback, North Carolina, 1946-1949
- George “One Play” McAfee, Halfback, Duke, 1937-1939
- Vince “Pat” Pazzetti, Quarterback, Wesleyan/Lehigh, 1908-1909, 1911-1912
- Claude Reeds, Fullback, Oklahoma, 1910-1913
- Bob “Horse” Reynolds, Tackle, Stanford, 1933-1935
- Bob “Suff” Suffridge, Guard, Tennessee, 1938-1940
Class of 1962
- Benny Lee “Purple Streak” Boynton, Quarterback, Williams, 1917, 1919-1920
- Guy “The Champ” Chamberlin, Halfback/End, Nebraska/Wesleyan/Nebraska, 1911-1915
- Dan “Tiger” Hill, Center, Duke, 1936-1938
- Cal Hubbard, Tackle/End, Centenary/Geneva, 1922-1924, 1926
- Philip King, Quarterback, Princeton, 1890-1893
- John “Cap” McEwan, Center, Army, 1913-1916
- Tuss McLaughry, Coach, Westminster/Amherst/Brown/Dartmouth, 1916-1954
- John “Jack” Minds, Fullback, Pennsylvania, 1894-1897
- Pat “Kangaroo Kicker” O’Dea, Fullback, Wisconsin, 1896-1899
- Joe Rouff, Guard, Texas A&M, 1935-1937
- Bill Spears, Quarterback, Vanderbilt, 1925-1927
- Andy “Polyphemus” Wyant, Guard/Center, Bucknell/Chicago, 1887-1894
Class of 1963
- Alex Agase, Guard, Illinois/Purdue, 1941-1943, 1946
- George Connor, Tackle, Holy Cross/Notre Dame, 1942-1943, 1946-1947
- Edwin “Goat” Hale, Quarterback, Mississippi College, 1915-1916, 1920-1921
- Ken Kavanaugh, End, Louisiana State, 1937-1939
- Lee “Bum” McClung, Halfback, Yale, 1888-1891
- Cliff “Monty” Montgomery, Quarterback, Columbia, 1931-1933
- Peter “Peter The Great” Pund, Center, Georgia Tech, 1926-1928
- Monk Simons, Halfback, Tulane, 1932-1934
- Ed “Cannonball” Tryon, Halfback, Colgate, 1922-1925
- Charles “Buck” Wharton, Guard, Pennsylvania, 1893-1896
- George Woodruff, Coach, Pennsylvania/Illinois/Carlisle, 1892-1905
Class of 1964
- Earl “Red” Blaik, Coach, Dartmouth/Army, 1934-1958
- Chuck Carroll, Halfback, Washington, 1926-1928
- Ray Evans, Halfback, Kansas, 1941-1942, 1946-1947
- Bob Herwig, Center, California, 1935-1937
- Pooley Hubert, Fullback, Alabama, 1922-1925
- Langdon “Biffy” Lea, Tackle/End, Princeton, 1892-1895
- Bill “Memphis Bill” Mallory, Fullback, Yale, 1921-1923
- Charles “Babe” Rinehart, Guard, Lafayette, 1893-1897
- Kyle “The Mighty Mustang” Rote, Halfback, Southern Methodist, 1948-1950
- Bill “Sprak” Sprackling, Quarterback, Brown, 1908-1911
Class of 1965
- Jack Cannon, Guard, Notre Dame, 1927-1929
- Merle “Maumee Flash” Gulick, Quarterback, Toledo/Hobart
- Tom Hamilton, Halfback, Navy, 1924-1926
- Brud Holland, End, Cornell, 1936-1938
- George “tank” McLaren, Fullback, Pittsburgh, 1915-1918
- Carl “The Grey Fox” Snavely, Coach, Buckness/North Carolina/Cornell/Washington (MO), 1927-1958
- Eric “Eric the Red” Tipton, Halfback, Duke, 1936-1938
- James “Froggy” Williams, End, Rice, 1946-1949
Class of 1966
- Everett “Ev” Bacon, Quarterback, Wesleyan, 1909-1912
- Albie “Little Boy Blue” Booth, Halfback, Yale, 1929-1931
- Chuck Carney, End, Illinois, 1918-1921
- Charlie “Chuck’n Charlie” Conerly, Halfback, Mississippi, 1942, 1946-1947
- Jim “Sleepy Jim” Crowley, Halfback, Notre Dame, 1922-1924
- Jack “Old Hatfield” Hubbard, Halfback, Amherst, 1903-1906
- Frank Juhan, Center, Sewanee, 1908-1910
- Dick “Kaz” Kazmaier, Halfback, Princeton, 1949-1951
- John McGovern, Quarterback, Minnesota, 1908-1910
- Edgar “Rip” Miller, Tackle, Notre Dame, 1922-1924
- Pete “Big Dog” Pihos, End/Fullback, Indiana, 1942-1943, 1945-1946
- Aaron “Rosy” Rosenberg, Guard, Southern California, 1931-1933
- Norm “The Dutchman” Van Brocklin, Quarterback, Oregon, 1946-1948
- Lynn “Pappy” Waldorf, Oklahoma City/Oklahoma State/Kansas State/Northwestern/California, 1926-1956
Class of 1967
- Slade Cutter, Tackle, Navy, 1932-1934
- Nathan “Big’n” Dougherty, Guard, Tennessee, 1906-1909
- Joel “Lil’ Joel” Hunt, Quarterback, Texas A&M, 1925-1927
- Cecil “Cece” Isbell, Halfback, Purdue, 1935-1937
- Abe “Miracle” Mickal, Halfback, Louisiana State, 1933-1935
- Greasy Neale, Coach, Muskingum/West Virginia Wesleyan/Marietta/Washington & Jefferson/Virginia/West Virginia, 1915-1933
- Wear Schoonover, End, Arkansas, 1927-1929
- Paul “Schweg” Schwegler, Tackle, Washington, 1929-1931
- Herb Stein, Center, Pittsburgh, 1918-1921
- Francis “Whitey” Wistert, Tackle, Michigan, 1931-1933
Class of 1968
- Eddie “Natick Eddie” Casey, Halfback, Harvard, 1916-1919
- Zora “Z.G.” Clevenger, Halfback, Indiana, 1900-1903
- Jonas “One Armed Admiral” Ingram, Halfback, Navy, 1904, 1906
- Henry “Hank” Ketcham, Center/Guard, Yale, 1911-1913
- Bobby “Gadabout Gladiator” Layne, Quarterback, Texas, 1944-1947
- John “Johnny” Pingel, Halfback, Michigan State, 1936-1938
- Eddie Rogers, End, Carlisle/Minnesota, 1896-1898, 1900-1903
- Clark Shaughnessy, Coach, Tulane/Loyola (LA), Chicago/Stanford/Maryland/Pittsburgh/Hawaii, 1915-1965
- Vince “Steve” Stevenson, Quarterback, Pennsylvania, 1904-1905
- Adam “Ad” Walsh, Center, Notre Dame, 1922-1924
- Albert “Ox” Wistert, Tackle, Michigan, 1940-1942
- Buddy Young, Halfback, Illinois, 1944, 1946
Class of 1969
- Knowlton “Snake” Ames, Fullback, Princeton, 1886-1889
- Chuck “Concrete Charlie” Bednarik, Center, Pennsylvania, 1945-1948
- George Brooke, Fullback, Swarthmore/Pennsylvania, 1889-1895
- Paul Buner, Halfback/Tackle, Army, 1899-1902
- George “Bad News” Cafego, Halfback, Tennessee, 1937-1939
- Pa Corbin, Center, Yale, 1886-1888
- Edwin “Babe” Horrell, Center, California, 1922-1924
- Les Horvath, Halfback/Quarterback, Ohio State, 1940-1942, 1944
- Jimmy Johnson, Quarterback, Carlisle/Northwestern, 1899-1905
- Larry Kelley, End, Yale, 1934-1936
- Bill “Wild Bill” Kelly, Quarterback, Montana, 1924-1926
- Johnny “Flying Dutchman” Kitzmiller, Halfback, Oregon, 1928-1930
- Gerald “Little Red Arrow” Mann, Quarterback, Southern Methodist, 1925-1927
- Art “Dirty Face” Poe, End, Princeton, 1896-1899
- Walter “Wally” Steffen, Quarterback, Chicago, 1906-1908
- Art “Beef” Wheeler, Guard, Princeton, 1892-1894
- Bud Wilkinson, Coach, Oklahoma, 1947-1963
Class of 1970
- Ed Bock, Guard, Iowa State, 1936-1938
- Josh Cody, Tackle, Vanderbilt, 1914-1916, 1919
- John “Jack” Dalton, Halfback, Navy, 1908-1911
- Tom Davies, Halfback, Pittsburgh, 1918-1921
- Albert Exendine, End, Carlisle, 1905-1907
- Clarence “Bert” Herschberger, Fullback, Chicago, 1895-1898
- Art “Doc” Hillebrand, Tackle, Princeton, 1896-1899
- Dixie Howell, Halfback, Alabama, 1932-1934
- Myles Lane, Halfback, Dartmouth, 1925-1927
- Frank “The Master” Leahy, Coach, Boston College/Notre Dame, 1939-1953
- Don “Midnight” Miller, Halfback, Notre Dame, 1922-1924
- Winchester “Win” Osgood, Halfback, Cornell/Pennsylvania, 1891-1894
- Bill Reid, Fullback, Harvard, 1897-1899
- Hunter Scarlett, End, Pennsylvania, 1905-1908
- Ernie Smith, Tackle, Southern California, 1930-1932
- Bud Sprague, Tackle, Texas/Army, 1922-1928
- Sam “Brinck” Thorne, Halfback, Yale, 1893-1895
- John Tigert, Halfback, Vanderbilt, 1901-1903
- Frank “Wick” Wickhorst, Tackle, Navy, 1924-1926
- Clint Wyckoff, Quarterback, Cornell, 1893-1895
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 1951-1960
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 1971-1980
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 1981-1990
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 1991-2000
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 2001-2010
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 2011-2020
College Football Hall of Fame Inductees 2021-2030